Should I Repair or Replace My Garage Door?

When your garage door needs repair, especially after several services, it may be best to consider a replacement. However, a new garage door is an investment, and the signs pointing to a repair versus a replacement aren’t always obvious.

With the right information, you can make an informed decision about whether you need a garage door repair or replacement for your Madison property.

Signs Your Garage Door Needs Repair

One common reason for garage door repair is cosmetic damage. This type of damage doesn’t affect your garage door’s daily operation and function, and can include scratches, chipped paint and dents. 

Issues that slow down your garage door’s performance and cause minor inconveniences, such as strange noises while opening and closing, also indicate that you need repairs. These can include:

• Broken springs or cables: The springs and cables help your garage door open and close smoothly. When these are broken, the door struggles to operate. If the damage isn’t severe, a repair can get the cables and springs working like usual again.
• Malfunctioning sensors or remotes: A qualified technician can examine and fix garage door sensors and remotes. Though they enhance the safety and convenience of your garage door, a malfunction doesn’t require a complete garage door replacement. 
• Sagging door sections: Sagging garage door sections are a cosmetic issue, but can become a functional problem if ignored for too long. If the structure is intact, reinforcing the affected sections can get the door looking and working normally again.

When to Replace Your Garage Door

Major structural damage calls for a garage door replacement. When your garage door can’t function normally, stops working completely or poses a safety hazard to you or others, a new installation would be the right option. Take a look at some more instances where a replacement is the best choice:

Frequent, Costly Repairs

Getting a repair now and then is normal, but when these become too much to handle financially, you may want to start thinking about a new installation. Generally, the frequency of repairs depends on how often you use your garage door and its type. 

There are no set guidelines, as every property owner’s needs and preferences differ. If constant repairs are impacting your finances and convenience, consider a replacement.

Aging Garage Door

If you’ve had your garage door for 10-20 years, replacing it may be better, even if it doesn’t have obvious damage yet. A garage door over 10 years old will eventually show signs of wear and tear, and getting a new installation can be more cost-efficient. 

A new, stylish garage door will also complement your property, and some modern products include features for better safety, function and efficiency. 

Poor Energy Efficiency

An inefficient garage door is expensive to maintain. If you’ve noticed a spike in your energy bills but haven’t changed how you use electricity, examine the door’s weatherstripping and insulation. 

If you’re unsure about the insulation, you can try this easy test. Close your garage door and stand next to it. If you feel a draft, you may have an insulation issue. A new door with stronger panels and tighter seals can enhance insulation, giving your HVAC system a break and improving energy efficiency.

Outdated Garage Door Design

An outdated garage door design may not interfere with its performance, but an old design that hurts your property’s curb appeal is another reason to consider a replacement. 

Getting a new installation that blends with your property’s exterior can complete the look of your home or business. It can also add value to your property if you plan on selling.

Safety and Security Concerns

Some damage, like a bent frame and rotting material, can make a garage door unsafe, requiring a replacement. If your garage door has big gaps due to misaligned tracks or several loose panels that can easily be compromised, a replacement may be worth more than a repair. 

Serious rust can cause instability, such as a sudden collapse. Fixing severe damage isn’t worth the effort, and getting a new, safe garage door benefits your property and others. 

Key Considerations

If your garage door is old but doesn’t need frequent repairs, you can consider the following factors to help you decide whether you should get a replacement or repair:

• Technology upgrades: Smart garage door openers work best with new, modern garage doors. If you want features like remote management and better insulation, a new garage door offers high-quality parts and advanced components.
• Return on investment (ROI): A repair won’t offer the same ROI as a new installation, which may add more value to your property.
• Staying or selling: Your plans will also influence your decision. If you remain at your property long-term, you can enjoy the benefits of a new installation for longer. If you’re going to sell, a repair may be less expensive, but remember, an older garage door can impact the property’s selling price. 

Repairing vs. Replacing Your Garage Door

The costs of servicing a garage door can vary depending on the contractor and the depth and duration of services. On average, repairing a garage door component, such as a spring or panel restoration, is more affordable than replacing your entire door. If the garage door has a minor issue and needs a quick repair, there’s no need to get a new garage door.

Replacement becomes more relevant when the repairs needed are major, frequent or your garage door is over a decade old. If you need a lot of repairs or a major restoration, a new garage door can give you a financial break while providing years of better service. 

An old garage door that doesn’t show signs of damage now will exhibit signs later down the line, making the costs of replacing a garage door cheaper in the long run. Weigh your budget against your needs and evaluate how a new garage door can add to your convenience.

When to Call a Professional

It’s best to call a professional for most garage door problems. They will take proper safety precautions and have the right equipment to repair cables and springs, fix roller doors, and handle any other issues. An expert can thoroughly and safely inspect the door and offer accurate advice, whether your concern is an aging door or damaged components. They’ll assess whether a repair or replacement makes more sense, maximizing the system’s lifespan and your investment. 

Still Deciding? Contact the Professionals at R&R Doors

A lot goes into determining whether you should replace or repair your garage door. It’s a big decision and investment, from costs to convenience and aesthetic concerns. R&R Doors is a family-owned garage door company, proudly serving Madison home and business owners with trusted garage door repair and installation services since 1986. Our friendly, professional technicians will be happy to assist you in making a suitable decision for your property and needs.

To get started and discuss the right option for your garage door, request an inspection by completing this online form today.